Is It Right to Lie?
"If you continue in my word, then you are truly disciples of mine; and you will know the truth, and the truth will make you free,” (John 8:32). When you are able to just tell the truth a huge burden will be lifted off your shoulders, and make your life a whole lot easier rather than a complete mess. Seen through Kant’s eyes, when you’re truthful, not a lot of situations will be difficult for you, but once you become that deceiving and lying type of person, you often will have to end up telling more lies to hide your first lie, which will have you in a web of lies and leave in a messy situation. So why lie when it has been clearly proven that it won’t make things any better. Should you tell the truth knowing you will pay the consequences for what you have done? Not a lot of people today will tell the truth, only to help benefit themselves and get out of whatever horrible situation they have got themselves into. Keeping promises is also something that can’t be held and taken seriously because of the intentions and what will be gained from not keeping any type of promise. Kant’s valid reasons on why lying isn’t right, and why keeping promises isn’t a good idea at all, can be seen through many observations that give us a better understanding of what’s right and what’s wrong
A lie is a statement that is always untrue and is supposed to trick or deceive and a lot of the times it is looked at as the right thing to do in certain situations. Examples would include telling the location of your brother from a drug lord who wants to kill him, a doctor telling his or her patient that the chances of surviving cancer are fifty- fifty, when the own doctor is positive and knows that the patient only has a couple of weeks to live. When in a situation where telling the truth is hard in that difficult situation, it almost seems that telling the truth is your last resort because you just can’t help yourself. Kant believes that lying is and will always be morally wrong. We human beings have a certain value we carry with us that is internal and cannot be deprived from us. Kant refers to human dignity and what he says about this is that we should be treated with respect and how you would want to be treated. Humans today will do whatever it takes to get what they want, only focused on themselves and believing what is seen as wrong, but in their mind to be morally right. Kant says that to be human you have the influence in yourself to make the right and wrong decisions, but also have to respect and honor not just yourself but the others around you. Lying has two main reasons of why it is morally wrong; you won’t have the power to now make the right decisions in the heat of the moment or even in the future, and it also steals others of being able to do the morally right thing in life. When lying to yourself it damages you internally because your moral worth is slowly fading away and leaves you second guessing yourself. When lying to others you are leading others on and having them decide on the lie you’ve told and as mentioned before human dignity plays a huge role in this area because in this situation it has been harmed and also their independence. You are now controlling them because you have them believing you and that just shows how many times that that the only focus is on your moral values rather than everyone else’s. Kant moral principle, the categorical imperative that denotes an unseen requirement that has a valid reason for certain circumstances, that is essential and reasonable in all means. Focusing on what is wanted for us applies because it focuses on all us human beings and how we all wish that everyone could treat everyone the same, and not just on oneself. To avoid this and destroying each other with lies and treating others the way we don’t want to be treated is simple – do not lie.
When we lie and get away with it, we know clearly that it brings us joy. But there is that small piece inside you that...
Cited: "John 8:32 Then You Will Know the Truth, and the Truth Will Set You Free."" John 8:32 Then You Will
Know the Truth, and the Truth Will Set You Free." N.p., n.d. Web. 01 Nov. 2013.
"Q1: Could I Rationally Act on My Maxim in ThePSW?" KANTIAN ETHICS. N.p., n.d. Web. 02 Nov. 2013.
Please join StudyMode to read the full document