"Manager exists to deal with uncertainty". Critically analyse using examples, how differing views on the nature of evidence can impact on the both management and organizations? See Notes & Appendix for more details on the paper.
Abhishek Singh, 2047092
University of Glasgow - MBA
If there is no uncertainty then manager’s role will be in question and if we take uncertainty into consideration then there is a need for manager to deal with it (Smith & Tomb, 2000). Manager’s role is to collect appropriate information, act upon evidence, make proper decision and reduce uncertainty (Smith, 2005). (Jauch & Kraft, 1996) argued that manager might seek uncertainties in the environment rather than to avoid them, e.g. Pharmaceutical companies make mistakes while creating medicines and patent them to create uncertainty about the direction of the chemicals in the minds of their competitors. Sometimes, manager’s become the author of their own misfortune (Smith & Fischbacher, 2009). So, do they somehow integrate risk and uncertainty in their decision making?
Risk society (Beck, 1992) has become more vulnerable post modernity. For example, there has been significant research on climate change but due to the differing views on the outcomes and the counter arguments on the domain specific results among the experts put it in a loop (Adger et al. 2003). This raises many questions, is science needed to be more sophisticated? Or can organizations maintain status quo and not react at all? Or act upon the evidence, but which evidence? Or “Differing views of people are often faulty” (Bazerman, 2002:50–1)?
This paper would discuss the essence of managers in dealing with uncertainty using different risk parameters. It would also try to build an argument on nature of evidence, politization of scientist and media influence. It will use an example of Climate change risk – a “borderless phenomena” (Smith & Fischbacher, 2009:3) and Kyoto Protocol as precautionary measure in discussing differing views and its impact on performance of management and organization.
2. Uncertainty Key Element
Uncertainty has been a significant area for research and scientific debates (Corbett and Durfee, 2004, cited in Smith, 2012) but (Spiegelhalter and Riesch, 2011) think it should be considered as a contingent phenomena. (Winter, 1987) Suggested that the value of a firm is University Of Glasgow - "Manager exists to deal with uncertainty". Critically analyse using examples, how differing views on the nature of evidence can impact on the both management and organizations? See Notes & Appendix for more details on the paper.
proportional to it complexities, its values are more inclined to patents, capabilities, machines, organizational structure, experts and so on. The attributes driving complexities from Winter’s (1987) perspective enhances complexities in organization and compound the problem for managers.
“It is necessary to differentiate between risk, which is an event with a known probability, and true uncertainty, which is an event with an unknown probability”. - (Costanza and Cornwell, 1992)
Uncertainty may be considered from a range of zero level for the certain events to the intermediate level for statistical uncertainty or known probabilities (risk) to high levels with uncertainty or indeterminacy.
Donald Rumsfeld’s famous statement that there are “known knowns” when he was secretary of defence of the United States (2001-2006). Known-knowns (Seely, 2003) – the things which we know we know, Known-unknowns (Seely, 2003; Glucksberg and McCloskey, 1981) – the things which we know we don’t know , unknowns-unknowns – the things which we don’t know we don’t know (Seely, 2003). In most cases we consider risks and uncertainties are related to each other but it would make more sense if looked in the dimensions of predictability and unpredictability (Smith & Calman, 2010; Jarvis, 2008). When tried to...
References: Ackerman, A. S, Toon, O. B. Stevens, D. E. Heymsfield, A. Ramanathan, J. V. Welton,E. J. (2000).” Reduction
of Tropical Cloudiness by Soot”
Adger, W. N. Brown, K. Fairbrass, J. Jordan, A. PaavolaJ, . Rosendo,S . and Seyfang,G . (2003). Governance for
sustainability: Towards a "thick" analysis of environmental decision making
Australian Bureau of Agriculture and Resource Economics (ABARE). (1997) Interview with greenhouse
economics modeller, Canberra, March 1997.
Bazerman, M.H. (2002). Judgement in Managerial Decision Making. 5th edn. New York: Wiley. 50-51.
Beck, U. (1996a), “Risk society and the provident state in Lash S Szerszynski B ans wyne B eds Risk,
environment and modernity: towards a new ecology sage, London, 27 43.
Beck, U. (1992), “Risk society:towards a new modernity sage, London, polity press, 1-55.
Beck, U. (1994), “The re-invention of politics: towards a theory of reflexive modernization in Beck U Giddens A
and Lash S Eds Reflexive modernization: politics, tradition and aesthetics in the modern social order”, Polity
Betts, R. A. (2000), “Offset of the potential carbon sink from boreal forestation by decreases in surface
albedo“, Nature 408, 187–190.
Böhringer, Christoph and Vogt, Carsten. (2003). Economic and Environmental Impacts of the Kyoto Protocol.
Bulkeley, Harriet. (2001), “Governing Climate Change: The Politics of Risk Society?”, Wiley-Blackwell,
Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series, Vol
Caldeira. K. and Wood, L. (2008). "Clobal and Arctic Climate Engineering: Numerical Model Studies."
Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society 366 (1882): 4039-56.
Cao, Mingkui & Woodward, F. Ian. ( 1998). “Dynamic responses of terrestrial ecosystem carbon cycling to
global climate change” Department of Environmental Sciences
Commonwealth of Australia. (1995). Greenhouse 21C: a plan of action for a sustainable
future Department of the Environment
Engau, Christian. Hoffmann, Volker. H. Busch, Timo. (2011), Airlines’ Flexibility in Facing Regulatory
Uncertainty: TO ANTICIPATE OR ADAPT? 3-7
Chu, D. Strand R. and Fjelland R. (2003), Theories of complexity: Common denominators of complex systems,
Complexity, 8, 3, 18-31.
Core, A. (2007) The Assault on Reason. New York: Penguin.
Draft, R.L. and Lengel, R.H. (1986), Organizational information requirements, media richness and structural
design, Management Science: 554-571.
Folke, C. (2006), “Resilience: the emergence of a perspective for social-ecological systems
Glucksberg, S. & McCloskey, M. (1981). “Decisions about ignorance:Knowing that you don’t know. Journal of
Experimental Psychology: Human Learning and Memory
Goldblatt, D. (1996), “Society theory and the environment, Polity Press, Cambridge
Hardaker, J. Brian, Raud. B.M. Huirne, and Jock , R. Anderson. (1997). “Coping with Risk in Agriculture”, New
York, CAB International.
Hodge, Bob & Coronado, Gabriela. (2007). “Understanding change in organizations in a far-from-equilibrium
world”, E:CO Issue Vol
IPCC. Climate change (2001): the scientific basis. Contribution of working group I to the third assessment
report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change
J, Hoffman. (2005).” Climate Change Strategy: The Business Logic behind Voluntary Greenhouse Gas
Reductions, California Management Review 47(3)
Jackson, R. B., and Salzman, J. (2010). "Pursuing Ceoengineering for Atmospheric Restoration." Issues in
Science and Technology 26(4): 67-76.
James, A. Hampton, Bayo Aina. J. Mathias Andersson, Humaira Z. Mirza, and Sejal Parmar. (2011) . Journal of
Experimental Psychology: American Psychological Association Learning, Memory, and Cognition
Jarvis, D. S. L. (2008). Theorizing Risk and Uncertainty in Social Enquiry: Exploring the Contributions of Frank
Jauch, Lawrence R. Kraft. Kenneth L. (1996). "Strategic Management of Uncertainty". Academy of
John A, Lee. (2001). “The lancet oncology”, volume2, Issue 12, Washington, BL direct: 772.
Jones , Roger N. (2001). “An Environmental Risk Assessment/Management Framework for Climate Change
Packard, K. and Reinhardt , F. (2000). What Every Executive Needs To Know About Global Warming. Harvard
Business Review, 125 78(4), 128e135,
Knight, F. (1921) Risk, Uncertainty and Profit. Boston: Hart, Schaffner & Marx.
Lehenbauer, Kruti Dholakia and Elliott, Euel W. (2012), decisionmaking, risk, and uncertainty: an analysis of
climate change poligy, Cato Journal, Vol
Langenberg. Heike & Peter, Aldhous. (2000)."Global warming:
A climate of uncertainty", Nature
Nordhaus, W. D. (2007). "A Review of the Stem Review on the Economics of Climate Change." Journal of
Economic Literature 45: 686-702.
Nordhaus, W. D. (2008). “A Question of Balance: Weighing the Options on Global Warming Policies”. New
Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press.
Olick, J.K. and Robbins, J. (1998). “Social memory studies: from collective memory to historical sociology of
Please join StudyMode to read the full document